
What Is Abnormal? Psychology Meets Power
Prof. A opens the series by asking the question underneath abnormal psychology: who gets diagnosed, and who gets punished? This episode introduces the four Ds, the biopsychosocial model, structural competency, Victor Rios's youth control complex, and Kendrick Lamar's "u" as a primary source for understanding how suffering gets narrated, labeled, and controlled.
Using current reporting and course frameworks, the episode traces how childhood behavior becomes criminalized, how structural racism becomes embodied stress, and how diagnostic categories have historically served as tools of social control.
Transcript provided for citation.
Chapter 1
The Question Underneath Abnormal
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Seven years old. <audio-tag tag="pauses"></audio-tag>Sometimes the age is the whole argument. Reporting from March 2026 on school-based arrests describes a child that young pulled into the juvenile justice system after being near a playground conflict. Not leading it. Not carrying out some grand act of violence. Just near it. And if that does not force a harder question, nothing will. Was the child deviant? Dangerous? Disordered? Or were they simply seven, standing inside institutions that know how to punish faster than they know how to understand?
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
That is where this course lives. Deviant behavior is not a list of labels to memorize and repeat back on an exam. It is a way of reading the world. I want you to look at a headline and hear four conversations at once: what behavior is being named, what suffering is being recognized or ignored, what law or policy is organizing the response, and who had the power to make this person legible as a problem in the first place.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Because deviance is never a neutral label. It sounds descriptive. It sounds clinical sometimes, even objective. But once institutions enter the scene, that label starts doing work. It can explain, excuse, contain, punish, or disappear people. It can open the door to treatment, or it can open the door to handcuffs. Same behavior, different body, different neighborhood, different outcome. That is not accidental. That is structure.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
And I want to be careful here. I'm not doing that lazy thing where we pretend psychology is fake and every diagnosis is just politics in a lab coat. No. Diagnoses can name real suffering. Real distress. Real impairment. They matter. But the fact that diagnoses can be useful does not mean they are untouched by power. Those are two separate claims, and mature thinkers can hold both.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So this episode is really a lesson in how to think. When a school, a court, a clinician, or a police officer decides whose behavior gets explained and whose behavior gets punished, they are not simply observing reality. They are interpreting it through norms, through institutions, through history, through race, through geography. That is the question underneath abnormal. Not just what is wrong, but who gets named, who gets managed, and who gets seen as fully human before the paperwork starts.
Chapter 2
The Four Ds and the Biopsychosocial Model
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Let's build the clinical foundation the right way. In abnormal psychology, the standard opening framework is the four Ds: deviance, distress, dysfunction, and danger. These are the classic markers used to ask whether behavior crosses from unusual into disordered. As a starting point, that's useful. Deviance asks whether behavior violates social or cultural norms. Distress asks whether the person is suffering. Dysfunction asks whether daily life is impaired. Danger asks whether there is risk to the self or to others.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Now, in this class, we do not stop at the definition. We interrogate the definition. Each D contains a question. Deviance: whose norms are doing the measuring? Distress: is the person suffering, or is an institution reacting to behavior it finds inconvenient? Dysfunction: unable to function in general, or unable to function in conditions built without their needs in mind? Danger: dangerous to whom, and according to whose threshold of fear?
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
That's not me trying to blow up the framework. It's me teaching you how to use it without becoming naive. If you take deviance at face value, you miss that norms are social products. If you take distress at face value, you can miss that some people suffer because the world around them is hostile, not because something inside them malfunctioned first. If you take dysfunction at face value, you may confuse adaptation with disorder. And if you take danger at face value, you can mistake perceived threat for actual harm.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
This is why the biopsychosocial model matters so much. Properly understood, it tells us biology, psychology, and social conditions interact. Not one after another like neat little boxes. Together. A biological vulnerability does not act alone. It meets family history, trauma history, housing instability, neighborhood violence, school conditions, and access to care. Same vulnerability, radically different outcome depending on the context.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
And here's the part students sometimes rush past: the social in biopsychosocial is not decoration. It is not the polite final sentence after the real analysis. It is part of the mechanism. Stress exposure matters. Resource deprivation matters. Surveillance matters. Policy matters. If the social world can shape cortisol, inflammation, hypervigilance, and long-term health, then structure is not outside the person. Structure gets under the skin.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So when we use the four Ds in this course, we're not using them as a checklist that settles the issue. We're using them as an opening move. Clinical language gives us a starting point. Critical analysis asks what that language reveals, what it hides, and who pays for the hiding.
Chapter 3
Structural Competency and What Clinical Frames Miss
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
This is where Metzl and Hansen help us sharpen the lens. Their argument is that cultural competency, by itself, is not enough. And to be fair, cultural competency was trying to solve a real problem. Clinicians needed to understand that patients do not all arrive with the same background, language, norms, or ways of expressing pain. Fine. Necessary even. But Metzl and Hansen say that approach still keeps the analysis too close to the individual encounter.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
In other words, it stays in the room. It asks, how do I understand this patient better? It does not ask enough about what shaped the conditions under which the patient had to arrive at all. A structurally competent approach asks what is upstream of the room. Housing. Insurance. Transportation. Food access. Policing. Zoning. School quality. Labor conditions. The infrastructure of inequality.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
They use the example of a Black woman in her sixties arriving late to an appointment and not taking blood pressure medication as prescribed. A narrow reading might ask whether she mistrusts the medical system, whether she understands instructions, whether culture is affecting compliance. A structural reading asks whether she has reliable transportation, whether the medication needs to be taken with food, whether there is food nearby, whether her schedule is constrained by work or caregiving, whether the neighborhood itself was shaped by discriminatory policy. Same patient. Different theory of causation.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
That distinction matters in criminal justice too. Inside the clinical frame, a youth may look oppositional, noncompliant, aggressive, inattentive. Outside the frame, we may find relentless surveillance, unstable institutions, under-resourced schools, and routine exposure to punishment. The behavior has not changed. The explanation has.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Metzl and Hansen outline several competencies for structural analysis, but the one I really want you to hold today is structural humility. That means refusing the fantasy that inequality can be reduced to bad choices, bad attitudes, or defective individuals. It means recognizing the limits of your own frame. Sometimes what looks like pathology is the sediment of policy. Sometimes what looks cultural is structural. Sometimes what looks like a patient's flaw is actually the system announcing its own design.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So no, structural humility is not softness. It is rigor. It is the discipline to say: before I label this person, I need to understand the architecture around them. Before I call this behavior irrational, I need to know what environment made it sensible. That is the move from noticing difference to analyzing power.
Chapter 4
Criminalizing Childhood in Real Time
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Now let's bring all of that into the present tense. Reporting on school-based arrests of very young children shows punishment entering childhood early, and not by accident. The point is not that one case slipped through. The point is that a pattern is visible. Children as young as six and seven can be pulled into disciplinary systems and juvenile processing for conduct that, in any humane analysis, should trigger support, de-escalation, or simple adult common sense.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Try the four Ds again, but turn them onto the system. Is it deviant to arrest a child for proximity to conflict? I would say yes, in the sense that it violates basic expectations about what childhood is and what schools are for. Is it distressing? Absolutely. The reporting and the broader discussion around juvenile contact are clear that this kind of system involvement can produce anxiety, PTSD symptoms, depression, and hypervigilance. Is it dysfunctional? Yes, because early system contact increases the likelihood of deeper system contact later. And is it dangerous? To the child, profoundly.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
But as I said earlier, description is not explanation. This is where Victor Rios becomes essential. In Punished, and especially in the chapters on Dreams Deferred and The Flatlands of Oakland, he describes the youth control complex: a network of institutions, including schools, police, probation, courts, businesses, and community actors, that do not simply respond to youth behavior but actively shape young people through surveillance, labeling, and punishment. The young person is not encountering one authority figure. They are moving through an ecosystem of control organized across Oakland’s flatlands, along spaces like International Boulevard, where everyday life and everyday criminalization happen at the same time.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
And let's be plain about race here. Rios is writing about Black and Latino boys in Oakland, and he is careful to show that criminalization is both material and symbolic. Material criminalization means stops, searches, handcuffs, suspensions, expulsions, probation, and jail. Symbolic criminalization means being read as a thug, a suspect, a problem before any charge exists. The current reporting on school arrests echoes that broader pattern, where Black and Brown youth are treated as if ordinary childhood conduct is evidence of future threat. Childhood becomes pre-criminalized. The child is read not as developing, but as emerging danger.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Now, one of the most important facts in this whole discussion is that schools in Oakland and Alameda County that shifted toward restorative practices saw African American suspensions drop by around forty percent. Forty percent. That number matters because it proves the punitive outcome was not inevitable. It was a policy choice. And that matters even more when you read Rios describing schools that treated victimized youth as threats, pushed them out under truancy rules, or folded school discipline into police logic. Schools can choose police-centered control, or they can choose restoration and conflict resolution. One choice expands the pipeline. The other interrupts it.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So when you hear that a very young child was arrested, do not stop at outrage. Ask the structural question: what set of policies made that response available, reasonable, and repeatable? Because if policy produced it, policy can undo it.
Chapter 5
When Structure Gets Under the Skin
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Let's talk about the body, because sometimes students hear structural analysis and assume we're floating in abstraction. We're not. In January 2026, a study in JAMA Network Open from researchers at Washington University reported that nearly half of the mortality gap between Black and white Americans could be attributed to cumulative lifetime stress from structural racism. Sit with that. Not just interpersonal prejudice in isolated moments. Structural racism across time.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
The researchers used a cumulative stress index, and the broader point is devastatingly clear: the body keeps score not just of trauma in the singular, but of inequality in the aggregate. The damage appears in biological pathways. Inflammation markers. Cortisol. Shortened telomeres. Earlier death. So when Metzl and Hansen say structural forces can produce symptoms or even methylate genes, that is not rhetorical flourish. That's a claim about mechanism.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Now connect that to youth under chronic surveillance. Rios shows us young people developing hypervigilance, that constant scanning of the environment, always reading for threat, always ready for the next stop, search, accusation, or humiliation. He also shows how this becomes ubiquitous criminalization: the police stop, the teacher’s suspicion, the merchant’s stare, the neighbor threatening to call law enforcement. If you strip that response from context, you can call it pathology. You can write it down as oppositionality, aggression, defiance, maybe conduct disorder. But in context, hypervigilance can be adaptive. If the environment is dangerous, being alert is not irrational. It's skill. Costly skill, yes, but still skill.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
That doesn't mean the person isn't suffering. I want to be very careful there. Adaptation can hurt. Survival responses can preserve life in one setting and create trouble in another. A body trained for threat does not magically relax because a teacher says, calm down, or because a clinician opens a file. The point is not to romanticize the response. The point is to interpret it accurately.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
And institutions often fail at that. They remove behavior from the conditions that produced it, then act shocked by what they see. The young person is restless, suspicious, reactive, defensive. The chart fills up. The discipline referral multiplies. The diagnosis starts to harden. Meanwhile the source material, the chronic exposure to structural danger, falls out of view.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So this chapter gives you one core lesson: structure is not just around people. It becomes embodied. Once you understand that, you stop confusing injury with defect quite so quickly. You start asking what happened, what keeps happening, and what kind of world would make this behavior unnecessary.
Chapter 6
Diagnosis, History, and Cultural Texts as Evidence
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
To close, I want to braid together diagnosis, history, and culture. If you study the history of abnormality honestly, one pattern keeps returning: when people threaten the social order, institutions sometimes pathologize the threat. In 1851, Samuel Cartwright coined drapetomania to describe enslaved Black people fleeing bondage. Think about that. The desire for freedom was framed as mental illness. The diagnosis did not discover a disorder. It protected a power arrangement.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Same logic, different era: homosexuality remained in the DSM until 1973. That fact alone should humble anyone who speaks as if diagnostic categories descend from heaven untouched by politics. The category changed because activism and institutional pressure changed. Which means social power helped organize what counted as illness to begin with.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
Bring that history forward and we get current diagnostic disparities. Black children are more likely to receive labels like conduct disorder or oppositional defiant disorder than white children displaying the same behavior. Again, the diagnosis may name real conflict. I'm not saying every label is invented out of thin air. I am saying the interpretive threshold, who gets the benefit of the doubt and who gets read as dangerous, is shaped by race, law, and place.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
That is why geography matters. Oakland matters in Rios. The flatlands matter. International Boulevard matters. Schools matter. Courtrooms matter. Neighborhoods matter. Law distributes surveillance unevenly, and geography tells us where that surveillance clusters. Rios also gives us the language of negative credentials and acting lawful: young people marked early as risky have to keep performing innocence in spaces already prepared to doubt them. So when someone is called deviant, we need to ask where, by whom, under what policies, and in relation to which racialized expectations.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
And then there is Kendrick Lamar's "u." I want to treat that song as evidence, not decoration. In "u," Kendrick performs a brutal internal monologue filled with shame, grief, self-blame, and what sounds like survivor's guilt. His voice cracks, slurs, collapses. The performance gives us suffering in texture, not just in category. A chart might note alcohol use, depressive symptoms, maybe dysfunction. But the song narrates the social and historical weight around the suffering: Compton, violence, loss, distance, obligation, guilt. That's what cultural texts can do. They preserve the lived density that institutions flatten.
Ms. Andrea Hagan aka Professor A.
So here is the takeaway for this week: diagnoses can name real pain, but they are also made inside history, law, geography, and racial order. Your task in this course is not to reject diagnosis or worship it. Your task is to read it critically, humanely, and structurally. <audio-tag tag="softly"></audio-tag>That is how we refuse easy labels and start seeing people clearly.